Live typing in one sentence
With live typing, the other person sees every letter a moment after you type it. There is no finished message that suddenly pops up. The text takes shape in front of them, with all its pauses, typos and corrections. Delete something and it disappears on their side too.
That is what sets live typing apart from the familiar "typing…" indicator. The indicator only tells you that something is happening. What is happening, you only find out once the other person hits send.
An old idea
None of this is new. The Unix program talk, from the early days of the internet, split the screen in two and sent every character immediately. If you chatted with it, you watched the other person write, because technically there was no other way.
Google Wave revived live typing in 2009 as part of an ambitious attempt to merge email and chat. Wave was shut down after a few years, but many people remember this one feature in particular. And in telephony there is Real-Time Text (RTT), a standard that sends text character by character. It is mainly meant for deaf and hard-of-hearing people, so that a call in text form flows as naturally as a spoken one.
The big messengers chose differently for good reasons. Finished messages are easier to store, deliver and search. And many people like to word a message carefully. Along the way, though, something that makes a conversation a conversation got lost.
Why it makes chatting feel like talking
In a conversation, you don't just hear the result. You notice when someone hesitates, searches for the right word, or breaks off a sentence and starts again. You can react before they have finished, and sometimes three words are enough to know where it's going.
An ordinary chat cuts all of that out. What remains is a series of finished blocks with a pause in between that could mean anything: the other person is thinking, is distracted, or is writing a long text they will end up deleting.
With live typing, that pause is filled. Three things change:
- It gets faster. You read along while they write and can already reply. The back and forth comes closer to a real conversation.
- It gets more honest. Someone who needs three attempts for one sentence shows something by doing so. A text that noticeably softens as it is written says more than any emoji.
- It gets less polished. Since every typo is visible anyway, there's little point in fine-tuning your wording. Many people write more casually as a result.
An example: you ask how the date went last night. In a normal chat, "It was nice" arrives after a minute. With live typing, you watch "Honestly? Kind of boring" appear, vanish again, and turn into "Honestly? Really lovely 😊". Almost the same answer arrives in the end. But you know there's more to the story.
The downside
Live typing isn't right for every situation. If you are writing a difficult message, you may not want your first angry draft to be read. And whatever you delete straight away, the other person may already have seen.
That leads to a few simple rules:
- Don't type anything the other person must not see, not even for a second.
- If you need time for a reply, write it somewhere else and paste it in. It then appears all at once.
- Use live typing with people you already talk to openly. For chatting with your landlord, there are better tools.
Some people find it strange at first to be watched while they write. After a few conversations that usually fades, just as you don't plan every word in advance on the phone.
Live typing and privacy
When every letter is sent immediately, the question is who else gets to see it. In HotTea, live drafts are end-to-end encrypted just like finished messages. Our server sees that you are typing, but not what. It keeps a draft in memory for at most 30 seconds unless a newer version arrives. If you leave the chat or empty the text field, your draft disappears from the other person's screen.
What you send is gone after 24 hours unless one of you saves it. Live typing fits that well: both make a chat more fleeting, like a conversation nobody records.
Who live typing is for
It works best between people who are close: a partner, close friends, someone you are just starting to talk to. When you are getting to know someone in particular, it shows more of the person than a series of carefully worded messages.
In a group of twenty people, on the other hand, it would be chaos. That's why HotTea keeps groups small: at most 10 people, each with their own live draft in the chat.
You can try live typing for free in your browser, without a phone number or email. How it works in HotTea is explained on the live typing page.